The retail value of these palettes is $160 ($150 for the eyeshadow pans, $10 empty palette) so you actually save $75. So if you don't mind the depotting process then you can still customize these eyeshadows any way you like but you would have to purchase an empty palette, which still costs less than purchasing these eyeshadows separately. However, the overall price makes each shadow less than $6 so no need to get the Makeup Geek dupe when you can just get the original for less. That also means if a shade runs out you won't be able to just pop a replacement pan. That's a big let down as one would assume you could easily mix and match shades from all the palettes or even add some of your own. While the larger palettes are a great value and include full-sized eyeshadows, it's important to note that the pans are actually glued to the palette. * shade also included in another Eyes x 15 palette Sketch, burgundy with red shimmer (velvet).Star Violet, pinky brown plum (veluxe pearl).#Noir, deep black brown with gold pearls (velvet).Antiqued, ash brown with bronze (veluxe pearl).Poppyseed, mid-toned mauve nude (satin).Honeylust, bronze dipped peach (lustre).Black Tied, black with silver sparkle (velvet)Įyes on Mac, Burgundy Times Nine and Purple Times NineĮye Shadow x 9: Burgundy Times Nine ($40).Club, red-brown with green pearl (satin).Mulled Over, matte cool blue gray (matte).Copperplate, muted mid-tone gray (matte).Blonde Milk, pale khi with sparkles (lustre).Pepper Please, sparkly bronze copper brown (velvet).Ricepaper, peachy gold with shimmer (frost).Eyes on Mac, Amber Times Nine and Navy Times NineĮye Shadow x Nine: Amber Times Nine ($40)